The Scripts That Make Difficult Conversations Easier
Alisa Cohn
Executive Coach · Top 50 Coach, Thinkers50 #1 Startup Coach, Global Gurus (4 yrs running)
EXECUTIVE COACHING
Core Framework
Why Difficult Conversations Feel Impossible
"You're uncomfortable when they start crying. But honestly, the only way you're going to help someone grow is by leaning into these tough conversations."
Identify what you're really dreading — the reaction, the drama, looking wrong?
The meaning you put on top of a conversation shapes whether you have it
The other side of upset: new possibility, revelation, even joy and freedom
Not giving feedback is a choice — it has consequences too
The Scripts
Exact Language for Performance Feedback, Promotions & More
Script: Peer Feedback Issue
"Matilda, I wanted to chat with you about what I'm hearing from your peers about the way you're all interacting. They're flagging missed deadlines and your team not being in the loop. We both know the most important thing for your success here is that people can count on you — so I want us to leave this conversation knowing how you'll fix that."
Script: No Promotion This Cycle
"I know this is going to be challenging to hear — I'm not going to promote you right now. But I want you to know it's really important to me that you succeed in your career here. I want to help you find opportunities to build your skills and advance."
"What I'm hearing from your peers…" — diffuses it from a personal attack to multi-source signal
"We both know…" — positions you as an ally, not an adversary; credits their intelligence
"I want us to leave this conversation knowing…" — ends with a clear action item, not an open wound
"Hope for the future" — even the hardest message needs a path forward attached to it
Even keeled, matter-of-fact tone signals: "This is fixable. I'm not angry."
The relationship reservoir
Give specific positive feedback before the hard conversation — so they hear criticism through the lens of "she tells me when things are working too," not "she hates me."
Leadership Trap
Your Job Is Not to Make People Happy — It's to Help Them Win
"They're trying to be the leader who everyone loves. But you don't want to push them because you don't want to upset them — and ultimately, that leads to the demise of your company."
The avocado-toast trap: perks and socials become a substitute for clear expectations and results
High engagement comes from winning — structured goals, clear roles, celebrated milestones — not from making everyone comfortable
Culture = how we get work done, not what snacks we have. "We measure twice and cut once" is culture.
The right people want to join a team that wins, not a team that avoids hard conversations
The reframe
Making people happy = not having hard conversations.
Making people actually happy = building a team that wins, then celebrating wins together.
Playbook
How to Build the Difficult-Conversation Muscle
Step 1 — Mindset check: Ask yourself, "Am I doing this to vent or to help?" Only proceed when the answer is to help
Step 2 — Practice aloud: Literally wrap your mouth around the words before the meeting — not just in your head
Step 3 — Open neutrally: "I wanted to chat about something I've been hearing…" — matter-of-fact, not a verdict
Step 4 — End with action: "I want us to leave this conversation knowing X" — closes the loop, creates ownership
Step 5 — Build the reservoir: Give specific positive feedback regularly so hard feedback lands in trust, not fear
The "Thank you" data point
After a painful feedback conversation: "I wish someone had told me this 15 years ago. I could have had a different career." — Real report to Alisa, the day after she cried and went home early.
Contrarian
Alisa Cohn's Counterintuitive Takes on Leadership
✗If someone cries, the conversation went badlyINSTEAD →✓ Tears are not failure. The day after crying, Alisa's client said "Thank you — I wish someone told me this 15 years ago." Emotional reaction ≠ bad outcome.
✗A great culture means a happy, low-conflict teamINSTEAD →✓ Culture is "we measure twice and cut once" — the norms around how work gets done. Avocado toast and socials are not culture. Unclear expectations destroy culture faster than conflict ever will.
✗Visionary founders just need a great vision to lead wellINSTEAD →✓ Vision without structure = wheel-spinning. A founder who inspires but never sets goals or holds people accountable will frustrate and lose the people she inspires. Either build the structure yourself, or hire someone who will.
✗Scripts make feedback feel robotic and inauthenticINSTEAD →✓ Scripts are a starting point, not a cage. A formula that motivates you to actually have the conversation beats a perfect improvisation you never give. Make it your own — just start from somewhere real.